Parliament occupation 'a scar on NZ': Most vaccine mandates long gone, mistrust remains
Wednesday, 1 March 2023
Most of the vaccine mandates were lifted six months ago, but for many of 2022’s Parliament protesters, a deep sense of distrust of the Government remains.
Stuff spoke to several anti-mandate protesters last year during the three-week occupation, and though life has moved on – they’re back at work and the children are back in school – it would be fair to say emotional scars of the pandemic continue.
When the protest ended in a riot on March 2, hundreds had been arrested and dozens of police officers were injured. Journalist and politicians had faced daily threats. All up, the cost has topped $8m and is still growing.
The protest thrust conspiracy theories into the public view as anti-mandate and anti-vaccine protesters were joined by people spouting extreme views, all of which were streamed online.
Research showed the number of people consuming misinformation and disinformation online “exploded” during the weeks-long occupation of Parliament grounds. There was also rapid growth in subscribers to protest-related channels on Telegram – a largely unregulated messaging platform that has become a haven for violent extremists and conspiracy theorists.
**READ MORE:
* Wellington protesters heading to Cranmer Square, Christchurch protesters claim
* Distrust and freedom: Why the Parliament protesters came and stayed
**
At the occupation many protesters were exposed to conspiracy theories in person, when the ideas had previously only online.
Emma Gilbert, of the Far North, spent two weeks at the protest and was among the first to arrive at Parliament.
Both Gilbert and her husband lost their jobs due to the vaccine mandates, and they felt they needed to take a stand.
When restrictions were loosened, the Gilberts were able to get their hospitality jobs back, but some bitterness remained.
Rather than listened to, she felt protesters were abused in their efforts to effect change, and they didn’t achieve their goals.
“I didn’t feel that it was effective – I felt that we were ignored, and I didn’t think that that was what was meant to happen.”
Her family set up their campervan in Molesworth St and only decided to leave when the police presence was “getting stronger and stronger”.
“It was beginning to feel quite unsafe… so we left.”
Gilbert said she felt the conclusion of the protest turned into a “shambles” reminding her of her homeland of Northern Ireland where she emigrated from 25 years ago.
“I felt sad for New Zealand the way it ended.
“I was sad that there was so much division… there was a great break in the culture of New Zealand, and I don’t know that it’ll ever mend.”
Gilbert was glad to be back at work and not having to wear masks, but she said she still felt uneasiness in some everyday situations such as seeing the security guards when entering a supermarket.
Wellington electrician Matt Hunter was at the Parliament protests from start to finish.
'You've got to stand up for what you believe in, eh.
'It's probably one of the most significant things I've been through in my life.'
He said he had fond memories of the time, but admitted it ended horribly. He believed the Government was sticking to its agenda, and he was disappointed that the Prime Minister never addressed the crowd.
Though the restrictions had eased and life had returned to some kind of normalcy post pandemic, Hunter believed there would be lasting effects.
“I don't think we will ever be back to normal, will we?”
He was shocked by the way the occupation ended.
'It was horrible. It was totally unnecessary. A lot of people turned up who weren't there from the protest – they were just there to riot, and it was disgusting.'
Keith Smith, who lives on a lifestyle block in Ōpōtiki, said he was proud of his participation in the event and exercising his right to freedom of speech.
He felt very strongly about the impact Covid-19 lockdowns and vaccine passes had on the country during the pandemic. His father died during the Level 4 lockdown and Smith wasn’t able to be by his side.
He came down to the protest in the first convoy and was at the Parliament from the beginning.
”It had to be done. We were supposed to have a Government that listens to its people, and not everyone was happy with what was happening.”
He was in the camp when conditions started to deteriorate and decided to leave.
”I left because I knew what was going to happen. I saw people getting sick and stuff, and I wasn’t feeling well.”
The unvaccinated Smith doesn’t know if he had caught Covid-19 because he never got tested.
He said though a lot had changed in a year, he still felt New Zealand society was “slightly out of control”.
”I think there’s a lot of trauma from what was done. Covid’s gone but what was done has left a scar on New Zealand, which is pretty unfortunate.”
Though Covid-19 cases are a fraction of what they once were, there are still just over 1000 cases reported in New Zealand every day.
Kate Hannah, director of the Disinformation Project, said while some attendees felt disenfranchised and a sense of personal grievance, others were there to capitalise on it.
“They were making money from it and they were increasing people’s sense of alienation and grievance.”
There had been a continuing rise of mis and disinformation in the 12 months since the end of the occupation, she said.
“I think there was a lot of hope that once the traffic light system was dismantled, that this would go away. But the intent has never really been about Covid-19, the broader intent has been around disruption of New Zealand society and potentially disruption of New Zealand’s liberal democracy.”
Correction: An earlier version of this story suggested all vaccine mandates had been dropped. Some remain in the health sector. (Amended 12.04pm, March 2, 2023)