Queenstown risks becoming the ‘next Barcelona’, and locals are afraid

Sunday, 20 July 2025

Queenstown in July is magical.

Fairy lights twinkle along the lake front, shop windows glow warm against the frost, and snow-capped peaks frame the horizon. The air is crisp, the streets are bustling, and skiers and snowboarders spill out of rental shops, ready to chase fresh powder.

But there’s another, less enchanting light becoming increasingly familiar here: long, steady streams of red brake lights.

From Lake Hayes to the town centre, cars inch forward in dawn darkness and again as the sun sets — a new winter ritual as congestion strangles Queenstown’s fragile road network.

Once a remote mountain escape, the region is now grappling with the realities of urban-scale gridlock and becoming one of Australasia’s popular holiday destinations.

Queenstown’s growth story is staggering. Over the past four decades, the population has doubled roughly every 17 years — from 7000 to nearly 50,000. Within 30 years, it is predicted to be well over 100,000.

Its tourism recovery from the pandemic has been equally aggressive: international arrivals at Queenstown Airport are now 28% higher than in 2019. The average daily population peaks at just over 99,220. By 2053, that will be over 217,000.

Visitor spending hit $2.8 billion in 2023, with flow-on impacts estimated to contribute more than $1.3b to New Zealand’s national GDP. These visitors also generated 13,700–17,000 jobs nationally.

The local economy is increasingly high-cost and low-wage, with tourism placing enormous demands on a small ratepayer base. The average income in the region is $10,000 lower than the national average.

Infrastructure — built for a sleepy resort town — is now serving a city-sized population with few of the resources to match.

Across the Otago Central Lakes, councils estimate that between 80,000 and 100,000 new houses will be zoned for over the next 30 years.

Projected demand from actual residents sits at just 26,000. The rest is driven by tourism, holiday homes, short-term rentals, and property speculation.

It remains one of the most expensive places in New Zealand to buy or rent a home: approximately twice as expensive as anywhere else.

“Tourism has seriously lost its social licence,” outgoing Otago regional councillor Alexa Forbes says. “People are really tired of the impacts of tourism on their lives.

“We are going the same way as the Barcelonas and the Venices, which are starting to react badly to tourism.

“We might be a couple of decades behind, but the direction is the same, and unless we change anything, we're just on that path.”

A “sea of grey roofs”

Gridlock is the most visible symptom of Queenstown’s strain.

Queenstown’s network is already at capacity — with key routes like the Shotover Bridge exceeding peak volume 40% of the time.

By 2028, rush-hour trips are forecast to double. An 11-kilometre drive from the Lake Hayes Estate subdivision to the town centre is forecast to regularly take over 60 minutes.

Southland MP Joseph Mooney points to choke-points like the Kawarau Falls bridge, connecting Queenstown to Southland and Fiordland, which was upgraded in 2018 but is already overloaded.

Expanding the road network isn’t just expensive, it’s often physically impossible due to geographic constraints.

Local politicians want to see a major behavioural shift away from car dependence. But that’s not necessarily in step with what locals want.

Ladies Mile is one of Queenstown’s most notorious bottlenecks. A once-rural stretch of State Highway 6, it now serves as a critical commuter route, linking suburban developments like Lake Hayes Estate and Shotover Country to Frankton, the fast-growing commercial and residential gateway, and the town centre.

What was once a scenic approach, flanked by open paddocks and views to the Remarkables, has morphed into a congested arterial road where traffic routinely grinds to a crawl.

Within a few years, new housing subdivisions will line both sides, and locals fear it will become a permanent choke-point, effectively strangling Queenstown’s eastern access.

Late last year, the Government approved rezoning 120ha along the corridor, paving the way for 2400 new residential units and a commercial zone with a supermarket and service station.

That’s despite a significant majority of submitters (86%) opposing Queenstown Lake District Council’s draft ‘masterplan’ for the corridor. Around 80% objected to the density proposed, particularly the inclusion of high-rise blocks.

Almost two-thirds (60%) raised concerns about traffic congestion, and many submissions reflected scepticism about the uptake of public and active transport, arguing personal vehicle use was likely to remain high due to the Queenstown lifestyle and climate.

There was also opposition to the removal of minimum car-parking requirements.

Now, Queenstown Lakes District Council (QLDC) is consulting on further development in the Southern Corridor, a sweeping stretch of land south of the Kawarau River, encompassing Hanley’s Farm, Jack’s Point, and a newly-planned Homestead Bay development.

This is some of the country’s most sought-after real estate: a sun-drenched, open landscape cradled between the foothills of the Remarkables and Lake Whakatipu.

Once largely farmland, the area is now a canvas for high-end housing developments.

In the last five years, the population has boomed, soaring by 260% to 3840 residents. Officials believe it could support almost 10,000 homes.

Those who live there aren’t so sure. Consultation undertaken in 2023 and social media posts reflect strong feelings.

The phrase “a sea of grey roofs” cropped up in discussions with officials.

Locals used the term to express fears of monotonous, high-density sprawl, emphasising a clear preference for green spaces and thoughtful design over unchecked development. There was also considerable concern about congestion and Three Waters infrastructure.

One of the Government’s preferred growth levers — fast-track consenting — is adding fuel to the fire.

Among the most controversial is the Coronet Village: a proposed 780-house subdivision near Lake Hayes, packaged with a gondola project, backed by richlister and Xero founder Rod Drury.

The 400-strong Malaghans Valley Protection Society says it threatens wetlands and rural character, and relies on overstretched sewage systems.

“It's the headwaters of Lake Hayes. It's got a lot of wetland and a lot of history associated with it and … it doesn't have the infrastructure at all to manage another 780 houses,” society chair James Hall said.

“It would no longer be a beautiful green rural corridor.

“It's part of what makes Queenstown great and I think we have to be a bit careful about a lot of these things killing off the goose that laid the golden egg.”

He notes the development flies in the face of current planning rules. “Fast-track is a work-around all of that.

“We're not against planned growth. What we're against is opportunistic growth and not-thought-through growth.

“At the end of the day, Queenstown has to live with the fact that there are this huge number of applications and growing on top of what's already been approved for development and infrastructure that categorically is not coping currently.”

Homestead Bay, a 2800-unit proposal with commercial space and a marina, is more aligned with QLDC’s long-term vision, outlined in its 2021 spatial plan.

But residents are worried about rural land urbanisation and wastewater disposal, as well as traffic load on the already-congested SH6.

In total, nine fast-track proposals could add up to 13,000 new homes in the region — on top of what is already zoned.

The flaw, Hall says, is cumulative impact: “Panels look at each project in isolation. But nobody’s looking at the big picture — and the ratepayer ends up holding the bag.”

Wastewater

Earlier this year, a wastewater crisis became an inflection point for locals, galvanising community frustration and bringing long-standing concerns about accelerated growth and infrastructure to the fore.

The first signs that infrastructure wasn’t coping came in 2023, when Queenstown became ground zero for an outbreak of the parasitic illness cryptosporidiosis.

Human faeces had likely contaminated the drinking water supply because the Two Mile Water Treatment Plant lacked a protozoa barrier to protect against the bug. Water regulator Taumata Arowai issued a compliance order to the council ordering it to add the protections.

Then in March, another failure came to light.

The town’s wastewater treatment plant sits just downstream from the airport’s runway and close to the confluence of the Shotover and Kawarau rivers.

A land disposal field is positioned on the river delta. It’s a low-lying, flood-prone area of gravels and silts, on a popular cycle trail and within sight of tourist jet-boat routes.

The disposal field (where treated sewage is discharged onto land, rather than directly into waterways) launched in 2019 but failed almost instantly, leading to ongoing unconsented discharges.

But despite warnings over years, the full extent of problems was kept quiet until 2024 when local investigative news outlet Crux began digging and councillor-turned-whistleblower Nikki Gladding went public.

In 2025, the council began using emergency powers to dump more than 12,000 cubic metres of treated effluent per day into the glacier-fed Shotover River, known for its striking turquoise colour.

Locals were horrified and picketed the plant in March and April, not convinced by the council’s assurances that water quality would not be impacted.

“There are a lot of issues that people could protest about in Queenstown lakes [but] it was kind of a tipping point,” says protest organiser Queenstown Lakes Community Action's Nikki Macfarlane.

“It doesn't matter what your background is or what your beliefs or values are. We all want clean water.”

Macfarlane is heavily critical of QLDC, and said a lack of communication and consultation raised serious questions about how emergency powers were used and why the community was left out of the loop.

The council’s application to continue discharges is now headed to the Environment Court.

QLDC has allocated $77.5m to implement a new disposal strategy, which is expected to be in operation by the end of 2030.

Gladding is worried about a continuing discharge to the river, warning that even treated wastewater poses contamination risks from substances not fully removed by treatment (like heavy metals or chemicals).

And with the entire system relying on one large, vulnerable treatment plant near a river delta, there's little resilience, she says. More failures or a major earthquake could cause catastrophic untreated discharges.

“People use the Shotover River and the Kawarau River for recreation,” she says. “People fish in it. People kayak in it. And then, of course, that water flows down into Lake Dunstan at Cromwell.

“So there’s a big issue here, and there’s a lot of people affected.”

The council said its infrastructure boss Tony Avery was unavailable for interview.

Healthcare and energy squeeze

Healthcare, too, has failed to keep pace.

Funding is based on New Zealand averages, rather than reflecting the high visitor numbers. This means the local hospital is not adequately resourced for the large proportion of tourists it serves, even those who contribute financially.

GP clinics in the area report that approximately a third of their urgent-care patients are international visitors, a third are domestic tourists, and a third are locals.

“The local hospital here was built for 4500 people,” Mooney says. “The district as a whole, the Otago Central Lakes district, now is about 80,000 residents - and then you can have more than that in visitors on a given day. So we’re looking at how we can get better, publicly-delivered health service across that whole region.”

Residents must travel hours to Dunedin or Invercargill for specialist care. And even though a rebuild of Dunedin Hospital is going ahead, central government isn’t planning to fund a long-sought Queenstown Lakes base hospital.

The town’s isolation isn’t limited to health services: it’s also the largest urban area in New Zealand not connected to the national electricity grid, instead relying on a single spur line that leaves it exposed to both supply risks and higher power costs.

By 2032, demand is expected to outstrip supply, potentially adding $500 per household annually in electricity costs.

“We have a really big problem,” says Nick Leggett, chief executive of Infrastructure NZ, of the burden on Queenstown’s vital networks.

“And it needs to be solved, because Queenstown is one of the engine rooms of New Zealand.

“People need to be on-board with growth. When growth becomes a problem, and when the infrastructure system and the planning system doesn't allow enough forward investment to be able to cope and cater for growth, public support wanes.

“The progress has continued to fall back. And people feel that. They feel that in their everyday lives, their ability to move around where they live, to get their kids to school, to get to work at the right time, to being worried about where some people are sleeping, and the quality and the affordability of accommodation.

“Those are all massive challenges that we don't expect to see in a first-world country.”

Fast-track, slow fix

To tackle the crisis, the Government has just started negotiating a 10-year plan with a 30-year vision for the region with the region’s councils and backed by Ngāi Tahu.

Rather than pushing back against growth, the ‘regional deal’ accepts it but calls for smarter tools to manage it.

There will be little, if any, direct government investment. Instead it will help councils raise funds and access alternative financing options to keep pace with demand.

A light-touch proposal, a sort of wish-list, was submitted to the Government earlier this year. It suggests congestion charging, value-capture taxes and a local visitor user charge to fund 30% of needed infrastructure.

That’s despite Tourism Minister Louise Upston ruling out a ‘bed tax’ for tourism hotspots in April.

However, Mooney left the door open. “The options are open for discussions around how value will be captured best to fund the infrastructure that we need… and that’ll be part of the negotiation.”

The proposal includes a mass rapid transit system, potentially including gondolas, to move visitors around the basin while bypassing narrow roads, and a new bus service linking Cromwell, Alexandra, Wānaka and Queenstown.

The deal also calls for Queenstown to be included in the national grid. And a pilot ratepayer-assisted scheme would offer co-funded rooftop solar and battery systems to households.

The Queenstown Electrification Accelerator, an ambitious plan for the town to become the world’s most electrified destination launched last month. The pilot will build a low-cost, low-emissions, resilient energy system, combining local rooftop generation with traditional grid power.

“If we could have an infrastructure environment where households and farms and businesses were treated as an equal part of the energy system, we’d be able to deploy a lot more solar and batteries a lot faster,” says Josh Ellison of Rewiring Aotearoa.

“Historically, electricity infrastructure has been large-scale… But now, a combination of large-scale and small-scale operating together in the system is what’s going to work.”

Six health projects are a priority in the hoped-for deal, including a new hospital, maternity hub, aged care, and integrated care centre in Wānaka.

Mooney said a new clinical services plan, already under development by Health NZ and due back in December, will clear the way for a new hospital that could be the country’s first large privately-owned and publicly-operated hospital.

But expanding healthcare through public-private leasing models make some locals nervous that relying on private investment to fix the gaps could leave some residents behind, and might promote medical tourism.

Despite the regional deal being pitched as the fix, concerns linger that growth-focused solutions could deepen existing inequities - with locals questioning whether essential services will truly serve the community, or just the visitors fuelling the boom.

“This region is contributing billions to the economy,” Mooney insists.

“It’s punching above its weight. If we want to keep growing the economy, attracting skilled workers, and offering premium experiences to tourists - Queenstown has to work.”

What do you think? Email sundayletters@stuff.co.nz. Please include your full name and address.