It’s happening - Ruth Richardson accepts Nicola Willis debate challenge

Tuesday, 9 December 2025

After initially turning down a challenge from Finance Minister Nicola Willis to “come out of the shadows” and debate her directly, Ruth Richardson has changed her tune.

A debate could be on the cards as soon as next week, after the release of the half yearly economic fiscal update (HYEFU).

The Taxpayers’ Union has been planning an attack campaign on Willis from the right, asserting that she is increasing spending and debt despite pledging to fix the books.

Willis said Richardson - another National Party finance minister who undertook ruthless fiscal consolidation in the early 1990s, including sweeping benefit cuts - was clearly behind the campaign and should simply debate her directly.

“Instead of lurking in the shadows with secretly funded ads in the paper, come and debate me right here in Parliament,” Willis said.

Read more:

• National and Labour up in latest poll, as Greens and Te Pāti Māori fall

• Holding together while pulling apart - the changing coalition power dynamics of 2026

Willis “rejected” Richardson’s approach and wanted to test her “tolerance for human misery”.

“What I want is a straight up, honest debate to really analyse some of the claims that she and her associates are making, to argue about actually what the impact of some of the things that she is calling for would be on everyday New Zealanders and their families, to test what her tolerance for human misery is.

“If Ruth Richardson is as good as her word and is sincere in her argument - she’ll front up.”

Richardson earlier told The Post she wasn’t interested in “pistols at dawn” with Willis.

“This is a debate about policy, not about personality. I am not at all attracted to drawing pistols at dawn.”

But shortly after 5pm the Taxpayers’ Union issued a statement: 'Ruth is more than happy to debate the Government's debt, levels of public spending, balancing the books, and growth.

'The Government promised to reduce public spending. It's now higher than when Grant Robertson left office.'

'Ruth is ready to debate the sorry state of our fiscal position after the release of the HYEFU next week.“

Earlier, Richardson said Willis was “clearly feeling the pressure” because her own Treasury were yelling “fire, fire - we have a structural deficit that needs to be addressed”.

“The job for the Taxpayers’ Union is to hold her feet to the fiscal fire. That is the motivation.”

Treasury Secretary Iain Rennie has said the Government is running a “structural operating deficit”.

Last week Rennie said New Zealand “hadn’t fiscally consolidated” but had “reprioritised” in its last two budgets.

Prime Minister Christopher Luxon declined to comment on the upcoming campaign on Monday.